Which of my products are actually making me money after all the fees?
Most product sellers can’t answer this question because their books don’t capture the information needed to answer it. When a platform like Amazon, Shopify, or Etsy sends you a deposit, that deposit arrives net of fees. If you record the net amount as revenue, the fees vanish. You never see what they actually cost you, and you have no way to know which products are profitable after all costs.
True product-level profitability means taking what you sold the item for and subtracting product cost, platform fees, payment processing fees, shipping costs, and returns. Every one of those costs needs to be tracked separately in your books. Ideally you allocate each cost to the product or channel that generated it.
The common surprise is that bestsellers often have negative margins after fees. A product selling 500 units a month looks like a winner until you calculate that the platform takes 15 percent, payment processing takes another 3 percent, shipping eats a chunk more, and returns run higher on that SKU than others. After all costs, you might be losing money on every sale while celebrating the volume.
This visibility only exists when your books are set up to capture it. Recording gross sales instead of net deposits is the first step. Then you track platform fees, processing fees, and shipping as separate expense categories. You maintain accurate product costs and update them when supplier prices change. For businesses holding physical inventory, proper inventory accounting tracks what you have and what it actually costs.
Most accounting software can handle this structure, but someone has to configure it correctly and maintain the discipline month after month. ClearLedgers® works with e-commerce sellers and product-based businesses to set up books that reveal product and channel profitability. That’s the kind of detail you need to make smart decisions about what to promote, what to drop, and where to invest your energy.
If your current bookkeeping and payroll services aren’t showing you this level of insight, or if you’re ready to see which products truly earn their shelf space, book a consultation and let’s look at your situation together.
Relationship-First Bookkeeping for Small Businesses
The Next Step:
A Short Conversation
Tell us about your business and what you're dealing with. We'll listen, answer your questions, and explain how ClearLedgers can help.
More Questions
I sell online to customers in every state. Where do I actually owe sales tax?
You owe sales tax in states where your sales cross their economic nexus threshold. Most states use $100,000 in annual in-state sales, though some larger states set the bar at $500,000. Thresholds, measurement windows, and what counts toward them vary by state and require verification.
Read answerI run payroll through Gusto or ADP already. What could go wrong that I would not notice?
Payroll platforms execute what they're told, so the failure modes are all about configuration. Wrong GL mapping, outdated unemployment rates, benefit withholdings that drift from actual plan costs, and state notices sitting unread all happen quietly.
Read answerHow should a medical or dental practice reconcile what the practice software says to what hit the bank?
Match your practice management software's daily collections report to your actual bank deposits, tracking down every variance. Insurance EFTs, credit card batches, and patient payments each land differently, and the books only tell the truth when both sides tie.
Read answerI heard the 1099 reporting threshold changed. Which vendors get forms now?
The federal 1099 reporting threshold is scheduled to rise from $600 to $2,000 for payments made in 2026 and later, though 2025 payments still use the $600 threshold. Your W-9 collection practices should not change, and some states maintain their own lower thresholds.
Read answerWhat exactly is an estimated tax remittance service, and what is it not?
An estimated tax remittance service submits your quarterly estimated tax payments based on amounts from your tax return or tax preparer. It handles preparation, electronic filing, confirmation, and documentation. It does not calculate tax amounts, prepare returns, or provide tax advice.
Read answerMy business makes money on paper. Why is deciding anything still so hard?
Profit tells you the business made money overall. It doesn't tell you which services drive that profit, which customers are worth keeping, or where your next investment should go. Those questions take analysis of what's beneath the numbers.
Read answer
